Charter Scenario Test
Mark Breakdown
STEP 1 → IDENTIFY GOVERNMENT ACTION → 1 mark (1 COM)
STEP 2 → DETERMINE CHARTER VIOLATION → 4 marks
WHAT 1 COM
WHO 1 COM
HOW 1 KU & 1 APP details on form & content of the expression (Irwin Toy test) OR 3 stage s. 7 analysis
STEP 3 → DETERMINE IF A JUSTIFIED VIOLATION → 14 marks
VALID PURPOSE → 3 marks / 2 points & 1 precedent case (3 KU)
LOGICAL CONNECTION → 3 marks / 2 points & 1 precedent case (1 KU / 1 T / 1 COM)
MINIMAL IMPAIRMENT → 4 marks / 2 points & 2 precedent cases (2 T / 2 APP)
PROPER BALANCE → 4 marks / 2 points & precedent cases (2 T / 2 APP)
STEP 4 → REMEDY → 1 mark (1 COM)
STRIKE DOWN (entire section of law)
READ IN (paste new words into section of law)
READ DOWN (cut words out of section of law)
COMPENSATION (money)
DECLARATION (statement of recognition by court)
OR
Justified Violation NO REMEDY REQUIRED